Book review: The Fair Botanists

Women in science ruffling feathers in Victorian Edinburgh

By
Sarah Bancroft
Inverleith House at the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh
Rock Garden at the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh

The Fair Botanists, penned by Scottish novelist Sara Sheridan, is a captivating novel that seamlessly blends history, mystery, and the enchanting world of botany at the turn of the last century. Set against the backdrop of the 19th century Enlightenment in Edinburgh, this work of historical fiction takes readers on a journey through time and nature, weaving together a tapestry of compelling characters, intricate plot lines, and a deep appreciation for the beauty and mysteries of the botanical realm.

Sheridan's storytelling talent and attention to detail shines as she transports readers to the Victorian era, a time of burgeoning scientific discoveries, societal constraints, and the unquenchable thirst for exploration. The novel follows the lives of two remarkable women, Elizabeth and Isobel (Belle), whose paths are interwoven by their shared passion for botany. Elizabeth, a gentlewoman and botanical painter with an insatiable curiosity, is a recent widow relocated from London to Edinburgh to be a companion for an aging aunt. Belle, on the other hand, is a courtesan with aristocratic lineage who refuses to be confined by societal expectations and yearns for financial independence. They make an odd couple, especially after Elizabeth discovers her new friend’s profession, but ultimately they bond over a shared passion for plants. Their motivations, however, could not be more different. While Elizabeth finds solace and liberation through her charcoal sketches, Belle sees botanicals as a means to financial independence. She toils, along with a young male intern, in a makeshift laboratory, to create the ultimate perfume, a “Love Potion,” as she calls it, that will cement her fortune. She will go, it turns out, to any length the achieve it. 

One of the novel's most commendable aspects is Sheridan's meticulous attention to historical accuracy. The rich descriptions of the Victorian botanical gardens, the dress of the period, and even the auld English used throughout (time is described as “11 of the clock,” for example) evoke a sense of time and place that envelops the reader. The author's extensive research is evident as she delves into the intricacies of 19th-century botanical exploration, accurately depicting the challenges faced by female scientists in a male-dominated field. Women are not permitted to become doctors at this historical juncture (although Scotland will progressively—and controversially—reverse this constraint in the not too distant future). Several romantic story lines weave through the plot, and Sheridan notes, interestingly, that Scottish wives were permitted to keep their maiden names during that era. This historical backdrop adds depth to the characters' struggles and triumphs, making their journeys all the more inspiring and relatable.

At the heart of The Fair Botanists lies a celebration of women's resilience and ambition. Elizabeth and Isobel are both remarkable women ahead of their time, challenging societal norms and pursuing their passions with unwavering determination. Sheridan beautifully captures the complexities of their characters, portraying their strengths, vulnerabilities, and growth with great finesse. As readers witness their evolution, they become emotionally invested in their fates, cheering for their successes and sympathizing with their setbacks.

The novel's pacing is masterful, alternating between Belle’s risky trysts and the dark art of perfumery and Elizabeth’s domestic life at the grand family estate, Inverleith, in the company of a cohort of household help. Central to the plot is the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh, which borders on the estate, and the blooming of the Agave Americana, or Centurion plant, which happens only once in 30 years. Everyone, it seems, has a competing motivation as concerns this rare event, and this dynamic through-line keeps the reader engaged. Sheridan's prose is elegant and evocative, vividly describing the lush landscapes and intricate botanical specimens that populate the narrative. Her words paint a picture so vivid that readers can almost hear the trotting of the carriage horses and smell the fragrant blooms in the Victorian conservatories.

Mystery aficionados will find much to appreciate in The Fair Botanists as well. The novel is skillfully layered with intriguing plot twists, hidden secrets, and unexpected revelations. Meanwhile, Elizabeth’s quest to find her own voice becomes a journey of self-discovery, a foil to Belle’s botanical  and bawdy adventures. The intertwining lives of these two protagonists keep the reader engrossed, eager to unravel the truth behind the enigmatic events—and flowers—that shape the characters' lives.

The Fair Botanists seamlessly merges history, mystery, and the wonders of the natural world. Sheridan's meticulous research, eloquent prose, and multidimensional characters create an immersive reading experience that transports readers to the genteel gardens of Victorian England. The novel's celebration of women's tenacity, its captivating mysteries, and its profound appreciation for the beauty of botany make it an enjoyable, enchanting read.


Edinburgh will play host to the UK premiere of Fleurs de Villes VOYAGE from September 15 - 24, 2023. Sara Sheridan will be making an appearance to talk about her creative journey to write The Fair Botanists - see event details here.

The Fair Botanists, penned by Scottish novelist Sara Sheridan, is a captivating novel that seamlessly blends history, mystery, and the enchanting world of botany at the turn of the last century. Set against the backdrop of the 19th century Enlightenment in Edinburgh, this work of historical fiction takes readers on a journey through time and nature, weaving together a tapestry of compelling characters, intricate plot lines, and a deep appreciation for the beauty and mysteries of the botanical realm.

Sheridan's storytelling talent and attention to detail shines as she transports readers to the Victorian era, a time of burgeoning scientific discoveries, societal constraints, and the unquenchable thirst for exploration. The novel follows the lives of two remarkable women, Elizabeth and Isobel (Belle), whose paths are interwoven by their shared passion for botany. Elizabeth, a gentlewoman and botanical painter with an insatiable curiosity, is a recent widow relocated from London to Edinburgh to be a companion for an aging aunt. Belle, on the other hand, is a courtesan with aristocratic lineage who refuses to be confined by societal expectations and yearns for financial independence. They make an odd couple, especially after Elizabeth discovers her new friend’s profession, but ultimately they bond over a shared passion for plants. Their motivations, however, could not be more different. While Elizabeth finds solace and liberation through her charcoal sketches, Belle sees botanicals as a means to financial independence. She toils, along with a young male intern, in a makeshift laboratory, to create the ultimate perfume, a “Love Potion,” as she calls it, that will cement her fortune. She will go, it turns out, to any length the achieve it. 

One of the novel's most commendable aspects is Sheridan's meticulous attention to historical accuracy. The rich descriptions of the Victorian botanical gardens, the dress of the period, and even the auld English used throughout (time is described as “11 of the clock,” for example) evoke a sense of time and place that envelops the reader. The author's extensive research is evident as she delves into the intricacies of 19th-century botanical exploration, accurately depicting the challenges faced by female scientists in a male-dominated field. Women are not permitted to become doctors at this historical juncture (although Scotland will progressively—and controversially—reverse this constraint in the not too distant future). Several romantic story lines weave through the plot, and Sheridan notes, interestingly, that Scottish wives were permitted to keep their maiden names during that era. This historical backdrop adds depth to the characters' struggles and triumphs, making their journeys all the more inspiring and relatable.

Inverleith House at the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh
Inverleith House at the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh
Rock Garden at the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh
Rock Garden at the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh

At the heart of The Fair Botanists lies a celebration of women's resilience and ambition. Elizabeth and Isobel are both remarkable women ahead of their time, challenging societal norms and pursuing their passions with unwavering determination. Sheridan beautifully captures the complexities of their characters, portraying their strengths, vulnerabilities, and growth with great finesse. As readers witness their evolution, they become emotionally invested in their fates, cheering for their successes and sympathizing with their setbacks.

The novel's pacing is masterful, alternating between Belle’s risky trysts and the dark art of perfumery and Elizabeth’s domestic life at the grand family estate, Inverleith, in the company of a cohort of household help. Central to the plot is the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh, which borders on the estate, and the blooming of the Agave Americana, or Centurion plant, which happens only once in 30 years. Everyone, it seems, has a competing motivation as concerns this rare event, and this dynamic through-line keeps the reader engaged. Sheridan's prose is elegant and evocative, vividly describing the lush landscapes and intricate botanical specimens that populate the narrative. Her words paint a picture so vivid that readers can almost hear the trotting of the carriage horses and smell the fragrant blooms in the Victorian conservatories.

Mystery aficionados will find much to appreciate in The Fair Botanists as well. The novel is skillfully layered with intriguing plot twists, hidden secrets, and unexpected revelations. Meanwhile, Elizabeth’s quest to find her own voice becomes a journey of self-discovery, a foil to Belle’s botanical  and bawdy adventures. The intertwining lives of these two protagonists keep the reader engrossed, eager to unravel the truth behind the enigmatic events—and flowers—that shape the characters' lives.

The Fair Botanists seamlessly merges history, mystery, and the wonders of the natural world. Sheridan's meticulous research, eloquent prose, and multidimensional characters create an immersive reading experience that transports readers to the genteel gardens of Victorian England. The novel's celebration of women's tenacity, its captivating mysteries, and its profound appreciation for the beauty of botany make it an enjoyable, enchanting read.


Edinburgh will play host to the UK premiere of Fleurs de Villes VOYAGE from September 15 - 24, 2023. Sara Sheridan will be making an appearance to talk about her creative journey to write The Fair Botanists - see event details here.

BACK TO JOURNAL